Skip to main content
Call Us Youtube TikTok Linked In Instagram Facebook

Property Management Blog

Property Management vs Self Management: What’s Best for You?

Property Management vs Self Management: What’s Best for You?

Owning rental properties is an excellent way to generate steady income and grow your investment portfolio. But as a property owner or real estate investor, one of the most critical decisions you'll make is how to manage your properties.

Should you hire a rental property management company or tackle self-management? Each approach comes with advantages and challenges, so it’s important to carefully evaluate which option suits your goals, resources, and lifestyle.

This article will help you decide by breaking down each method, exploring key differences, and outlining factors to consider.

What is Property Management?

Property management involves hiring professionals or a property management company to oversee your rental properties. These experts handle essential tasks like tenant screening, rent collection, property maintenance, and marketing.

Essentially, they take on the responsibilities of managing your properties, freeing up your time.

Roles and Responsibilities of a Property Manager

A property manager wears many hats. They are responsible for tasks such as:

  • Tenant screening to find quality tenants.

  • Timely rent collection.

  • Regular property maintenance and resolving maintenance issues promptly.

  • Marketing rental properties to reduce vacancy rates.

  • Enforcing lease agreements and handling the eviction process when necessary.

  • Keeping the property compliant with fair housing laws and legal regulations.

Benefits of Hiring a Property Management Company

Working with experienced property managers offers several advantages:

  • Expertise in rental law, tenant screening, and property marketing.

  • Time savings, as property managers handle day-to-day tasks, including rent collection and maintenance requests.

  • Higher profitability through better marketing, competitive rent pricing, and reduced vacancy rates.

  • Access to a network of trusted contractors ensures good property maintenance.

  • Peace of mind knowing an expert team is managing your property.

However, hiring a property manager comes with property management fees, which typically range from 8%-12% of your monthly rent.

What is Self-Management?

With self-management, property owners or landlords personally take charge of every aspect of their rental property. From finding tenants to addressing late-night maintenance calls, you’ll be directly involved in your rental business.

While it offers greater control, self-management is not without its challenges.

Pros and Cons of Self-Management

Self-management has its own set of advantages and drawbacks:

Pros:

  • Cost savings by eliminating property management fees.

  • Complete control over key decisions, such as setting the rent price and screening potential tenants.

  • Hands-on involvement allows for a personalized approach to tenant management.

Cons:

  • Time-consuming tasks, like collecting rent, property inspections, or resolving tenant disputes, can feel like a second full-time job.

  • A lack of expertise in legal regulations or maintenance issues can lead to costly errors or property damage.

  • High stress levels, especially when dealing with emergencies such as a broken water heater or late-paying tenants.

Key Differences Between Property Management and Self-Management

Expertise

Hiring a property manager gives you access to professionals with years of experience dealing with legal regulations, rental law, and effective property management. Self-management requires you to gain this knowledge independently.

Time Commitment

Property management companies take daily administrative tasks off your plate. On the other hand, self-management ties you directly to the time-consuming responsibilities of managing properties.

Financial Investment

While hiring a property manager involves management fees, self-managing rental properties may also incur hidden costs, such as expenses for marketing, legal consultations, or emergency repairs.

How to Choose the Right Approach

Consider Your Property and Goals

Do you own multiple properties or live far from your rental units? If so, a property management company may be ideal. For single-unit owners who live nearby, self-managing could be manageable.

Evaluate Your Resources

Think about how much time you can dedicate and whether you have the required expertise. For instance, can you effectively screen tenants while complying with fair housing laws? Do you have reliable contacts for handling maintenance issues?

If you don’t, it may be challenging to self-manage successfully.

Weigh the Costs

Determine whether the potential increase in rental income and tenant satisfaction justifies the property management fees. Remember that good property managers can save you money in the long run by reducing vacancies and legal risks.

Make Your Choice Today!

There’s no universal solution when it comes to choosing property management vs. self-management. It all boils down to your personal preferences, resources, and long-term goals.

Property management companies can be a valuable option for property owners prioritizing convenience and professionalism. Conversely, self-managing is a great way to save money if you’re prepared to invest the time and effort required for success.

Still unsure about your next move? Partnering with a reliable property management company could be the key to achieving your financial goals while reducing stress.

Visit Stutts Properties to explore how professional property management can help you build and manage a successful rental property investment.

Other Resources:


What to Expect from Property Management Companies


Do My Property Management Fees Cover Rental Maintenance?

back